Positive Interference

Yesterday I commented on Jeremy Zawodny’s blog on a fundamental difference I see between Plaxo Pulse, FriendFeed and MyBlogLog and I wanted to expand a bit further here in the name of thinking out loud and getting a sense of what others think.

As I announced on the MyBlogLog blog a couple of weeks ago, we are getting close to releasing a feature which publishes an aggregated view of all your updates from services such as flickr, del.icio.us, YouTube, twitter, and others. This aggregated event stream has been called a number of things (vitality feed, activity stream, lifestream, mini-feed) but we’re simply calling it New with Me.

As more sites add this feature, there seems to be two approaches to what to do with this data. One the one hand you have sites like Wink and Profilactic which simply pull in updates and republish them. MyBlogLog’s approach is like this. On the other, you have sites such as Plaxo Pulse and FriendFeed which are hosting specific actions such as adding comments around the content aggregated on their sites.

The question is, what is the value of hosting comments on a site that is removed from the place that generated the content? If I’m feeding my updates to a site such as Pulse or FriendFeed, I would rather be able to keep the conversation threads all together on my site or at least tie them together with something like a trackback to pull in threads if the discussion jumps over to another venue. The way Pulse and FriendFeed are built, your readers can never know what additional discussion is taking place which makes it an open loop of dis-jointed conversations that may never come together.

Bret Taylor from FriendFeed responded with a perspective that shed light on his perspective which didn’t occur to me. In his response to my comment on Jeremy’s post, Bret says that FriendFeed is less a distribution platform but more, “a forum for private discussion with people you know.” But why break off what likely to be the most thoughtful commentary and keep it from the others that might benefit from it if they are not your friend?

I look for inspiration from a broad variety of sources and thrive on the serendipity of unintended consequences. This morning I was listening to a podcast because there was a mention of a term I follow that dropped it into one of my tracking feeds. In it, Jeff Schmidt, a bassist that is also quite thoughtful on the latest social media technologies threw out a line that struck me.

I love being open to the possibility of positive interference.

That describes what I most love about the online world in which we live. The way that someone halfway around the world can stumble into your world and zap you with a turn of phrase that crystallizes a new way of looking at things. This happens best in a world where comments are open and thoughts are shared together in a way that everyone benefits. It’s all about Doc Searls’ Snowball.

Bret and I are on a panel together next week at the Graphing Social Patterns conference in San Diego and I really look forward to learning more what others think. It should be a fascinating discussion!






12 responses to “Positive Interference”

  1. Patrick Avatar

    I love the idea of having a central place to see all of your news feeds. Spock.com actually just released a similar news feed section. You should check it out if you get a chance.

  2. Justin Henry Avatar

    Hosting comments on a site that is separate from the original content is helpful when the place where the content lives doesn’t allow you to make comments. For example, this means that I can finally comment on my del.icio.us bookmarks.

  3. Eric Marcoullier Avatar

    Man, I am more bummed than ever that I’m missing Graphing Social Patterns. Rock the house on the panel and let me know how it goes!

  4. FriendFeed launches; where’s lifestreaming headed? Avatar

    […] the focus from the origination source to the aggregation destination(s). Ian Kennedy from MyBlogLog questions, “what is the value of hosting comments on a site that is removed from the place that […]

  5. Lifestream Blog News for March 3rd 2008 | Lifestream Blog Avatar

    […] Positive Interference | everwas – Post from MyBlogLog Product Manager Ian Kennedy about Lifestreaming services hosting comments around content pulled in from 3rd party services […]

  6. Olivier D. ze kat Avatar

    I feel you about “comments” features… You are in touch ;o)

  7. Robert Scoble Avatar
    Robert Scoble

    Funny. I found this blog by seeing a comment on FriendFeed.

  8. ian Avatar

    Hi Robert,<br />
    <br />
    That's weird that you would find reference to such an old post on FriendFeed. A search on the title shows that the last time this post would have bubbled up in anyone's feed is via delicious back in late-February.<br />
    <br />
    <a href="http://friendfeed.com/search?q=positive&quot; target="_blank">http://friendfeed.com/search?q=positive</a&gt; interference&amp;service=&amp;public=1&amp;who=<br />
    <br />
    I guess that's what drives me nuts about this service. I'd love to know where you found the reference!

  9.  Dating Avatar

    Radio communication technologies has ensured that the range in which radio controlled autos has been elevated with no interference to other radio equipment in the vicinity. Some RC vehicles have memory devices which …

  10. Sohana Malik Avatar
    Sohana Malik

    What a wonderful blog you have created. I just stopped in to tell you I really appreciated the read 

    and shall be dropping by from time to time now.

  11. Miniclip Avatar

    I was definitely enjoying every little bit of it and
    I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

  12. cell phone spyware Avatar

    very interesting  nice piece of sharing thx

Leave a comment